Chapter 17 Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

⚠️ This page contains detailed discussion of Chapter 17 (Chapter 19 in this edition) of Open Water, including plot developments and thematic analysis. If you have not read this chapter yet, you may want to return after finishing it.

Summary

The chapter opens with the woman away in Dublin for a week, apartment hunting. She has left the search late, with only a few weeks of summer remaining. During this separation, the narrator and the woman do not explicitly discuss what happened between them before she left. The narrator reflects that their bodies have already communicated everything that words might attempt to say, and so silence feels acceptable. From a distance, they fall into a rhythm as if it were effortless.

When she returns, the narrator waits for her at the airport, perched on top of the empty help desk, swinging his legs like a joyful child. She walks through the evening terminal and waves; he waves back, his heart swelling at the small gesture. This reunion is understated but emotionally charged.

The chapter then shifts into a meditation on trust. The narrator recalls an earlier idea that trust is not about filling time, but revises this: trust is filling time with each other. He compares the heart's work—filling with blood and clenching it out, tight as a fist with nothing in hand—to the way they fill time, clutching at it as it slips away, and clutching after each other during the moments they must be apart.

Their days together are built on weekly routines: shopping, mind-numbing television, cooking, cleaning, reading. They sit perched separately but together, and often find themselves near the balcony when it rains. Thunder and lightning break the heat, and the narrator describes these sounds in musical terms, like snare hits and hi-hats.

The chapter closes with an extended musical metaphor. The narrator compares the two of them to a pair of jazz musicians, forever improvising. Or perhaps they are not the musicians at all, but their love manifests in the music itself. With his head tucked into her neck, he can feel her heartbeat thudding like a kick drum. Her smile is a grand piano, the glint in her eye like the twinkle of hands caressing ivory keys. The rhythmic strum of a double bass evokes the inert grace she possesses, moving her body in ways that astound him. They are a pair of soloists in conversations so harmonious that one struggles to separate them. The narrator concludes: they are not the musicians but the music.

Key Events

The woman spends a week in Dublin apartment hunting, having left it late with only a few weeks of summer remaining.
The narrator and the woman do not discuss what happened between them, but fall into a rhythm from a distance.
On her return, the narrator waits at the airport, sitting atop the empty help desk, and they exchange waves.
The chapter reflects on trust as filling time with each other, rather than merely passing time.
They settle into domestic routines: weekly shopping, television, cooking, cleaning, reading.
They often find themselves near the balcony during rain, with thunder and lightning breaking the heat.
The narrator describes their connection through jazz imagery, concluding they are not the musicians but the music itself.

Character Development

The narrator continues to process the relationship through sensory and musical language rather than direct dialogue. His decision to wait at the airport, perched on the help desk with swinging legs, reveals a childlike openness and vulnerability that contrasts with the more guarded posture he has sometimes adopted earlier in the book. His revision of the idea of trust—from not filling time to filling time with each other—shows emotional growth and a deepening commitment. He is learning to inhabit the ordinary rhythms of a shared life, finding meaning in weekly shops and quiet domesticity.

The woman is shown primarily through the narrator's perception, but her actions carry weight. She has been apartment hunting in Dublin, suggesting a practical, forward-looking orientation—she is building a life, perhaps one that includes him. Her wave across the airport terminal is a small but significant gesture of recognition and warmth. The narrator's descriptions of her grace, her heartbeat, and her smile indicate that she embodies a kind of effortless beauty and presence that he experiences almost musically.

Together, they demonstrate a relationship that has moved past the need for constant verbal explanation. Their bodies communicate; their routines create a shared structure; their silences are comfortable rather than fraught.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Trust as filling time. The narrator explicitly revises his earlier understanding of trust. Rather than trust being the absence of time-filling, it becomes the act of filling time with each other. The heart's rhythmic clenching becomes a metaphor for how they hold onto each other across separation.

Jazz improvisation as relationship. The extended jazz metaphor suggests that their connection is not scripted but improvised, responsive, and collaborative. Like musicians, they listen and respond to each other, creating something harmonious that neither could produce alone.

Bodies communicating beyond words. The narrator notes that there is little to say that their bodies have not already said. This theme reinforces the novel's broader interest in physical, non-verbal forms of intimacy and understanding.

Domestic routine and intimacy. The weekly shops, television, cooking, cleaning, and reading are not presented as mundane or dull but as the fabric of a shared life. These routines are the containers within which trust is practiced and love is sustained.

Rain and storm imagery. The balcony during rain, with thunder and lightning breaking the heat, evokes both turbulence and release. The storm is described musically, as snare hits and hi-hats, linking natural phenomena to the jazz motif.

Love as music. The chapter's final movement insists that the narrator and the woman are not merely like musicians but are the music itself. Love is not something they perform; it is something they become.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is a turning point in the novel's emotional arc. After the tensions and uncertainties of earlier chapters, it offers a portrait of the relationship settling into a sustainable, joyful rhythm. The airport reunion and the domestic routines that follow suggest that the couple has found a way to be together that feels natural and unforced.

The chapter also crystallizes the novel's central aesthetic: the use of jazz as a structuring metaphor for love, communication, and identity. By concluding that the narrator and the woman are not the musicians but the music, the chapter asserts that their love is not something they do but something they are. This is a profound statement of union and mutual becoming.

Finally, the chapter's meditation on trust—revising an earlier idea—shows the narrator's capacity for growth and self-correction. He is not static; he is learning, adapting, and deepening his understanding of what it means to be in love.

Study Questions and Answers

1. How does the narrator's understanding of trust change in this chapter?

The narrator recalls an earlier idea that trust is not about filling time. He revises this to say that trust is filling time with each other. The heart's rhythmic clenching—filling with blood and releasing it—becomes a metaphor for how they hold onto each other, even in separation. Trust is not passive emptiness but active, shared presence.

2. What role does the jazz metaphor play in describing the relationship?

The jazz metaphor frames the relationship as improvisational, responsive, and collaborative. The narrator compares them to a pair of jazz musicians forever improvising, with her heartbeat as a kick drum, her grace as a double bass, and their conversation as harmonious soloists. The metaphor culminates in the idea that they are not the musicians but the music itself, suggesting their love is not performed but embodied.

3. Why is the airport reunion significant?

The airport reunion is significant because it demonstrates the narrator's willingness to be openly vulnerable and joyful. He waits perched atop the empty help desk, swinging his legs like a child, and his heart swells at her wave. The scene shows that separation has not weakened their connection but has clarified it, and the small gesture of a wave carries enormous emotional weight.

Navigation

← Previous Chapter | Book Hub | Next Chapter →