Chapter Thirty-seven: Naya Confronts Her Fear of Love
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
A week after her fight with Jake, Naya visits Aaron while Felicia and the kids are away. She arrives in messy clothes, and Aaron quickly sees she needs to talk. Naya reveals her conflict with Jake, the pressure from the president’s committee, and that Davis (her abusive ex) has been texting her—though she refuses to discuss the texts in detail. Aaron pushes her to examine her behavior: she kept the relationship secret, blamed Jake for things out of his control, and then stopped talking to him. He argues that her real fear is being hurt again, and that she must give Jake a chance to love her, flaws and all. Aaron also notes that Naya has never introduced Jake to her friends, proving she hasn’t fully let him in.
Later that night, Naya texts Jake. He responds while drunk, revealing how much her silence hurt him. He accuses her of being scared and heartless, saying she only wants something temporary. Naya apologizes repeatedly but cannot bring herself to type “I love you.” The chapter ends with Jake stating, “You want temporary. You got it,” leaving Naya in regret.
Key Events
- Naya visits Aaron after a week of avoiding Jake.
- She admits Davis has been texting her, but refuses to discuss it.
- Aaron points out Naya’s pattern of pushing people away out of fear.
- He challenges her to trust Jake and let him into her life completely.
- Naya texts Jake; he replies drunk and angry.
- Jake expresses deep hurt, accusing Naya of being heartless and only wanting a temporary connection.
- Naya apologizes but fails to say she loves him.
- Jake ends the exchange, implying their relationship is over.
Character Development
Naya – This chapter forces Naya to see her own self-sabotage. Aaron’s blunt observations make her realize she has been protecting herself by keeping people at a distance. Her inability to text “I love you” highlights her deep fear of vulnerability. She acknowledges her mistakes but remains paralyzed by past trauma.
Jake – Though he appears only through texts, Jake’s drunken messages reveal his emotional pain. He drops his usual composure and exposes his fear of being used. His accusation that Naya is “heartless” shows how her actions have damaged his trust.
Aaron – Acts as a voice of reason. He balances empathy with tough love, steering Naya toward self-reflection without coddling her. His perspective underscores the difference between being “happy alone” and being too afraid to try.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Fear of Vulnerability – Naya’s refusal to say “I love you” even when she feels it exemplifies the chapter’s central theme. She is terrified of giving Jake the power to hurt her.
Communication Breakdown – The chapter contrasts productive conversation (Naya with Aaron) with destructive silence (Naya ignoring Jake). The drunk texts highlight how unspoken feelings fester.
Self-Sabotage – Aaron’s line “you want to cut him off before he has the chance to hurt you” captures Naya’s pattern. She ruins good things to avoid potential pain, a motif carried from earlier chapters.
Trust as a Choice – Aaron’s argument that “you won’t know until you get out of your own way” frames trust as an active decision rather than a passive reward.
Why This Chapter Matters
Chapter 37 is a turning point for Naya’s emotional arc. Aaron’s intervention forces her to confront the defense mechanisms she has built since her abusive relationship with Davis. The drunk text exchange with Jake shows the real-world consequences of her avoidance—her silence has caused genuine hurt. By ending with Naya still unable to say “I love you,” the chapter leaves her at a critical crossroads: she must either take the risk of true intimacy or lose Jake permanently. This moment also recontextualizes earlier chapters, making Naya’s reluctance to introduce Jake to her friends and her overreaction to the job threat more understandable as symptoms of a deeper fear.
Study Questions and Answers
Q1: What does Aaron’s advice reveal about Naya’s primary obstacle?
A1: Aaron identifies that Naya’s main obstacle is her fear of being hurt again. She has convinced herself she is “happy alone” but actually uses solitude as a shield. He points out that she pushes people away preemptively, assuming all men will betray her like Davis did.
Q2: How does Jake’s drunken texting contrast with his usual controlled demeanor?
A2: Throughout the novel, Jake is portrayed as measured and considerate. His drunken texts—with typos and raw accusations—reveal the depth of his hurt. He admits he was “so sure you were the fucking love of my life,” showing that Naya’s silence shattered his trust and made him feel used.
Q3: Why can’t Naya type “I love you” at the end of the chapter?
A3: Naya wants to say it, but her trauma prevents her. Saying those words would mean fully committing and making herself vulnerable to potential rejection or betrayal. Her past with Davis taught her that love can be weaponized, so she freezes, even though she knows Jake deserves to hear it.
Previous Chapter
Book Hub
Return to How to Fail at Flirting Hub