Chapter summaries Hour of the Witch Chris Bohjalian

Chapter 32 Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

The chapter opens with Douglas Webber meeting Oscar Bolton in a park across from an Episcopal Church in New York City. Oscar has just come from a brunch with ER doctor Alexis Remnick, and he is eager to share what he learned. Douglas initially resents the unscheduled meeting but quickly appreciates Oscar's thoroughness. Oscar reports that Alexis mentioned a lab researcher named Sara Edens and that she had been discussing rats with her. Alexis also asked Oscar directly whether he had ever been inside Austin Harper's apartment. Oscar lied, saying no, but the question unsettled him.

Douglas absorbs this information and concludes that Alexis is becoming a liability. He reasons that Austin Harper's greed started the unraveling, but Alexis is likely to finish it unless she is eliminated. Douglas tells Oscar to trust his instincts, praising his judgment. He then instructs Oscar to call Wilbur Sinclair, a scientist at the university labs, and arrange a meeting under the pretense of a potential research funder. Oscar is to have Sinclair invite Alexis to the labs, using Sara Edens as a lure—Sinclair should claim that Edens requested a tour. Douglas specifies that Alexis should be invited for one o'clock, though he allows for flexibility. Oscar makes the call, and Sinclair agrees to meet within forty-five minutes.

Douglas explains to Oscar that Alexis's death will be staged as a suicide. He notes that her boyfriend's death in Vietnam was ruled an accident, so a grieving girlfriend taking her own life would seem natural—even romantic. Douglas reassures Oscar that he need not be present for the final act, but he will be an accessory regardless. The scene ends with Douglas reflecting on the inconvenience of working on a Saturday, confident that the plan will succeed as it always has.

The chapter then shifts to Toril Bjornstad, an embassy officer in Cambodia. She has learned from Captain Nguyen about the energy gels Austin Harper brought to Vietnam. Toril concludes that Harper was a courier or salesperson, not the chemist behind the plague. She suspects the food chemist who was to buy the pathogen is dead, but she believes the operation was not a solo effort. She also wonders whether Binh Pham's group is connected to her late brother's rat research in Ho Chi Minh City.

Toril learns that the FBI is tracking Alexis Remnick. They are uncertain whether Alexis was Harper's accomplice or an innocent dupe. The FBI is preparing to raid the hospital and university labs, but the operation is delayed because the labs pose a biohazard risk in a densely populated city. Toril reflects on the nature of betrayal, recalling cases from her time in America where family members discovered the crimes of loved ones. She imagines Alexis's future: if she was not Harper's partner, she will soon learn that the man she loved carried plague across the planet and planned to sell it to a food chemist who intended to pass it to North Korea. Toril feels pity for Alexis, concluding that the situation cannot end well for her.

Key Events

  • Oscar Bolton reports to Douglas Webber about his brunch with Alexis Remnick, mentioning her conversation with Sara Edens about rats and her question about Austin Harper's apartment.

  • Douglas Webber decides Alexis must die and plans to stage her death as a suicide.

  • Douglas instructs Oscar to contact Wilbur Sinclair and arrange a lab meeting, using Sara Edens as a lure to invite Alexis.

  • Oscar makes the call, and Sinclair agrees to meet; the plan is set for Alexis to arrive at the labs by one or two o'clock.

  • Douglas explains that Alexis's death will look like a grieving girlfriend's suicide, making it appear natural and unsuspicious.

  • Toril Bjornstad learns about the energy gels and concludes Harper was a courier, not the chemist.

  • The FBI is tracking Alexis and preparing to raid the hospital and university labs, but the operation is delayed due to biohazard concerns.

  • Toril reflects on betrayal and imagines the devastating truth Alexis will face if she was innocent.

Character Development

Douglas Webber emerges as a cold, calculating mastermind. He dismisses Alexis's life with clinical detachment, referring to her death as inevitable and even romantic. His confidence is chilling: he believes the plan will succeed because it always has. He also shows a manipulative side, praising Oscar to secure his loyalty while making him an accessory to murder.

Oscar Bolton is increasingly complicit. He lies to Alexis about being in Harper's apartment and follows Douglas's instructions without fully grasping the consequences. His instinct to trust Douglas is both a survival mechanism and a moral failing. He asks about suspicion but accepts Douglas's reassurances, showing his willingness to be led.

Toril Bjornstad provides a contrasting perspective. She is methodical and empathetic, piecing together the evidence while feeling genuine pity for Alexis. Her reflections on betrayal reveal a seasoned observer of human darkness, yet she remains compassionate. She represents the investigative side of the story, highlighting the global implications of the plot.

Alexis Remnick is not present but is central to the chapter. Her actions—asking about Harper's apartment and discussing rats—trigger the murder plot. The reader sees her as both a potential victim and a possible accomplice, though the narrative leans toward her innocence.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Rats appear as a recurring motif. Alexis's conversation about rats with Sara Edens is the catalyst for Douglas's decision. Rats symbolize disease, betrayal, and the hidden dangers lurking in the labs. Douglas also muses that pigeons are called “rats with wings,” but rats are more easily weaponized, reinforcing the theme of biological threat.

Staged suicide is a central motif. Douglas's plan to make Alexis's death look like a grieving girlfriend's suicide underscores the theme of deception. He sees it as a natural, even romantic narrative, highlighting his twisted sense of order.

Trust and instincts are explored through Douglas's advice to Oscar: “Trust your instincts.” Douglas frames instinct as a survival tool, but he uses it to justify manipulation. Oscar's instincts lead him to Douglas, while Alexis's instincts—asking questions—lead to her doom.

Betrayal permeates the chapter. Alexis may be betrayed by Harper, who hid the plague from her. Oscar betrays Alexis by lying. Douglas betrays any pretense of morality. Toril reflects on the many forms of betrayal she has witnessed, emphasizing its universality.

Surveillance is evident in the FBI's tracking of Alexis and the impending raid. The chapter contrasts the covert operations of Douglas with the official surveillance of the FBI, both closing in on Alexis.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is a turning point in the thriller. It confirms Douglas Webber as the primary antagonist and reveals the extent of his ruthlessness. The plan to murder Alexis raises the stakes, making clear that no one is safe. The shift to Toril's perspective broadens the scope, showing the international consequences of Harper's actions and the FBI's response. The chapter also deepens the moral complexity: Alexis is a sympathetic figure, yet her fate is sealed by forces she cannot see. The raid on the labs promises imminent action, while Douglas's confidence sets up a potential confrontation.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Douglas Webber decide that Alexis Remnick must die?

Douglas believes Alexis is a threat because she is asking questions about Austin Harper's apartment and has made contact with lab researcher Sara Edens to discuss rats. He concludes that her curiosity could unravel the entire operation, so he decides to eliminate her before she can cause more damage.

2. How does Toril Bjornstad's perspective differ from Douglas's?

Toril is an investigator who seeks the truth and feels empathy for Alexis. She sees the human cost of the plot, imagining the devastation Alexis will face if she learns the truth about Harper. Douglas, in contrast, views people as obstacles to be removed, showing no remorse or concern for the lives he destroys.

3. What role does the motif of rats play in this chapter?

Rats symbolize the hidden biological threat and the betrayal that lurks beneath the surface. Alexis's conversation about rats triggers Douglas's murder plan, while Douglas's own thoughts about weaponizing rats highlight the sinister nature of the lab research. The motif ties together the themes of disease, deception, and the dangers of scientific ambition.

Navigation

Published by What Happened?

How this guide was made Report an error