Chapter 14 Summary: January 6, 2021
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
The chapter opens on January 6, 2021, with Em, Roddy, and Bonnie Rae watching live television coverage of the storming of the U.S. Capitol. Em publicly calls it awful and insists Roddy turn it off, but privately she is fascinated. She sees Donald Trump as a sorcerer who has turned the middle class into revolutionaries, and a dark part of her hopes the insurrectionists hang elected officials. After Roddy switches off the TV, he complains about his arthritic hands, and Em applies a yellow lotion made from the body fat of their previous victim, Peter Steinman. While Em treats Roddy’s hands, they discuss Bonnie, who has been hired to organize correspondence and applicant records. Roddy worries about killing someone so close to them, but Em persuades him that Bonnie’s personal troubles—a recent breakup, a strained relationship with her mother, and workplace sexual harassment—would make her disappearance plausible. Em also notes that Bonnie’s body fat is valuable for their arthritis relief. Roddy remains cautious but agrees to consider the plan. The chapter ends with Em returning to play the role of a helpless old academic while Roddy goes back to watching the riot.
Key Events
- Em and Roddy watch the January 6 Capitol riot on television; Bonnie Rae is present.
- Em secretly revels in the violence, imagining the insurrectionists hanging lawmakers.
- Roddy struggles to pick up the remote due to arthritis, highlighting his physical decline.
- Em uses a jar of human-fat lotion (harvested from Peter Steinman) to treat Roddy’s hands.
- Em and Roddy discuss making Bonnie their next victim; Em argues the proximity is justified by Bonnie’s vulnerabilities.
- Em reveals she has already gathered information about Bonnie’s personal life: breakup, controlling mother, harassment at work.
- Roddy initially objects because they have never taken someone with a close association; Em counters with the example of Jorge Castro.
- The couple agree on a tentative timeline: they would wait until after Bonnie’s part-time employment ends, months later, to reduce suspicion.
- Em returns downstairs to continue pretending to be a helpless academic, while Roddy returns to watch the riot on another TV.
Character Development
- Emily “Em” Harris: This chapter deepens Em’s duplicity. In public she performs disgust at the riot, but her internal thoughts reveal a thirst for violent chaos. Her casual racism (refusing to capitalize “blacks“) and homophobia (calling gay men “fanny-fuckers”) expose her deep bigotry. Her manipulative skill is on full display as she systematically dismantles Roddy’s objections to killing Bonnie, using cold logic and emotional leverage. Her use of human fat as lotion confirms her utterly amoral view of other people as resources.
- Rodney “Roddy” Harris: Roddy is more cautious than Em, worried about the danger of a close associate. His physical frailty (arthritis) makes him dependent on Em’s treatments, tying him to her crimes. He also objectifies Bonnie (commenting on her “fine rack”) but ultimately yields to Em’s persuasion. His eagerness to watch the riot suggests he shares some of Em’s dark curiosity.
- Bonnie Rae: Although present in the scene, Bonnie is seen only through Em and Roddy’s predatory lens. She is kind, eager to please, and unaware of the danger she is in. Her personal struggles (breakup, controlling mother, harassment) are cataloged by Em as vulnerabilities to exploit.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- Political violence as a mirror for personal violence: The Capitol riot on television reflects the Harrises’ own insurrection against social norms. Em’s approval of the mob’s violent overthrow of order parallels her own willingness to destroy individual lives for personal gain.
- The banality of evil: Em discusses her plan to murder Bonnie in the same tone she uses to ask about a form letter. The mundane domestic setting (watching TV, applying lotion, discussing a to-do list) normalizes the horror.
- Exploitation of the vulnerable: Em deliberately targets Bonnie because of her youth, isolation, and troubles. The chapter critiques how predators prey on those seen as disposable.
- The body as commodity: The human-fat lotion literalizes the idea of using people for their physical parts. Bonnie’s breasts are reduced to a percentage of body fat; the lotion provides pain relief, blurring the line between medicine and murder.
Why This Chapter Matters
Chapter 14 is a pivotal chapter for character revelation. It exposes Em’s true nature as a gleeful nihilist and bigot, not merely a serial killer but someone who revels in societal collapse. It also advances the plot by establishing the motivation and plan to kill Bonnie Rae, raising the stakes for the remainder of the novel. The January 6 backdrop adds a layer of historical commentary on American violence, connecting individual malice to larger political currents.
Study Questions and Answers
-
How does Em’s reaction to the Capitol riot differ from the reaction she shows to Roddy and Bonnie?
Em outwardly calls the riot “awful” and insists Roddy turn off the TV, but her internal narration reveals she finds it “awfully exciting.” She hopes the insurrectionists hang elected officials and admires Trump as a sorcerer who mobilized the middle class. This dichotomy shows her skill at hiding her true, violent beliefs. -
What arguments does Em use to convince Roddy that killing Bonnie is safe?
Em lists several factors: Bonnie’s recent breakup, her fraught relationship with her mother, and workplace sexual harassment from her head librarian. Em argues that if questioned, they can truthfully say Bonnie was unhappy and might have left town. She also notes that Bonnie will have left their employment months before any disappearance, further distancing them from suspicion. -
What does the human-fat lotion symbolize in this chapter?
The lotion symbolizes the characters’ complete objectification of other people. It is made from Peter Steinman’s body fat and used to treat Roddy’s arthritis. Em later refers to Bonnie’s breasts as approximately four percent of her body fat, suggesting Bonnie will be processed in the same way. The lotion blurs the line between medical necessity and cannibalism.
Navigation
- Previous Chapter: Chapter 13 Summary
- Next Chapter: Chapter 15 Summary
- Book Hub: Holly Summary and Analysis