Hard to Kill: Chapter 79 Summary and Analysis
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
After falling asleep, Jane dreams of her mother surrounded by hummingbirds—a rare happy dream in her current life. Waking with a smile, she makes coffee and goes to her neat basement to retrieve the hummingbird feeder her father once made for her mother. The memory of her mother’s lessons about feeding the birds surfaces vividly: the perfect four-to-one ratio of water to sugar, the importance of frequent cleaning, and the idea that the birds’ return is a miracle. As a child, Jane had asked if that was a real miracle, and her mother replied, “Is there any other kind?”
After buying her own house, Jane hung the feeder in view of her kitchen window, greasing the pole to deter ants. For a long time the birds came, and Jane grew to love them as much as her mother had. But when cancer struck Jane, the happy memories became tainted with death. During the trial of Rob Jacobson, she neglected the feeder, letting it dry out, until the birds stopped coming. She finally packed it away.
Now, in the present, Jane cleans the feeder thoroughly and mixes fresh sugar water. The simple work clears her mind of worries about Licata, Martin’s fate, Eric Jacobson’s connections, and the pretrial motions she must file before starting chemo. She rehangs the feeder, admiring it through the kitchen window. In a world that feels meaner and more dangerous, the feeder looks beautiful, just as it did in her dreams. She tells herself that if the birds return, it will be a sign she could use.
Key Events
- Jane dreams of her mother surrounded by hummingbirds and wakes smiling.
- She retrieves her father’s handmade hummingbird feeder from the basement.
- She recalls her mother’s detailed instructions on feeding and cleaning the feeder.
- Jane remembers how she once cared for the birds, but stopped after her own cancer diagnosis.
- She cleans the feeder thoroughly and mixes a fresh sugar-water solution.
- She rehangs the feeder outside her kitchen window, hoping the birds will return.
- She considers the feeder’s return a potential sign of hope in her difficult life.
Character Development
-
Jane is shown in a vulnerable yet introspective light. The dream of her mother reveals her longing for comfort and a connection to happier times. Her decision to rehang the feeder indicates a renewed willingness to nurture something beyond herself, despite her ongoing battle with cancer and the pressures of her legal work. The chapter deepens her emotional complexity, showing that beneath her tough exterior she still seeks signs of hope.
-
Jane’s mother (deceased) appears only through memory and dream. She is depicted as a loving, wise figure who taught Jane to see miracles in everyday events. This backstory humanizes Jane and explains her attachment to the hummingbirds.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
-
Memory and Nostalgia: The entire chapter is built on Jane’s vivid, sensory memories of her mother—the instructions about sugar and water, the placement of the feeder, the sound of the birds. Memory becomes a source of both pain and comfort.
-
Hummingbirds as Hope and Renewal: The hummingbirds symbolize the possibility of return, migration, and life continuing even after hardship. Jane’s act of rehanging the feeder is a gesture of faith that something good can come back to her.
-
Cancer and the Body: Cancer is the invisible antagonist here. It not only threatens Jane’s life but has also poisoned her relationship with happy memories. The routine of cleaning the feeder offers a small, controlled act of self-care amid medical chaos.
-
Ritual as Anchoring: The careful steps of cleaning, mixing, and rehanging function as a grounding ritual. The “honest work” clears Jane’s mind, providing a temporary reprieve from the threats surrounding her (Licata, Jacobson, legal pressures, impending chemo).
Why This Chapter Matters
Chapter Seventy-Nine is a quiet, introspective pause in a thriller otherwise driven by action and legal maneuvering. It reveals the emotional core of Jane’s character and shows how her past informs her present struggle. The chapter also introduces a symbolic object—the feeder—that may appear again as a marker of hope or despair. By ending on the ambiguous phrase “I could use one” (a sign), the author leaves readers wondering whether Jane will get the miracle she seeks, or if this moment of peace is merely a respite before greater danger.
Study Questions & Answers
-
What does the hummingbird feeder represent for Jane, and why does she decide to clean and rehang it now?
The feeder represents her connection to her mother, to happier childhood memories, and to a belief in small miracles. She rehangs it because the dream of her mother inspires her, and because she craves a sign of hope as she faces cancer, legal battles, and threats. The act is a deliberate step toward reclaiming something she loved before illness took over. -
How does the chapter use the contrast between past and present to develop Jane’s character?
The contrast shows how cancer has shifted Jane’s perspective: memories that once were joyous now carry associations with death and dying. Yet by choosing to repeat her mother’s ritual, Jane actively reframes those memories, asserting that she still values beauty and hope even in a “meaner, more dangerous” world. This demonstrates her resilience and capacity for emotional growth. -
Why does Jane refer to the birds’ return as “a sign,” and what does this reveal about her state of mind?
Jane is in a period of deep uncertainty—about her health, her cases, and her safety. The idea of a sign reveals her desire for external confirmation that things will improve. It highlights her vulnerability and her need for something intangible to hold onto, showing that even a hardened attorney can rely on hope and superstition when facing the unknown.