Chapter summaries First Lie Wins: A Novel Ashley Elston

Chapter 18 Summary: Alias: Mia Bianchi—Six Years Ago

⚠️ Spoiler Notice

This chapter reveals critical backstory about the protagonist’s past jobs, her methods, and how she begins building her own network. Proceed only if you are ready for plot details from the "six years ago" timeline.

Summary

Six years before the novel’s present-day events, the narrator works under the alias Mia Bianchi, embedded in Andrew Marshall’s Tennessee gubernatorial campaign. She has been employed by the mysterious Mr. Smith for over two years, receiving orders through his intermediary, Matt. The job differs from her previous assignments: instead of stealing files or objects, she must manufacture blackmail against Marshall, a genuinely good man with no hidden scandals. After three months of gaining Marshall’s trust, she receives instructions to set up a honey trap at a Hilton Head conference. Knowing Marshall will not cheat on his wife, she preemptively recruits a tech specialist named Devon to provide backup. At the conference, she drugs Marshall, invites corrupt politicians to a private party, and pivots to create compromising situations for them instead. The chapter establishes her shift from reckless operative to a calculated strategist building her own team.

Key Events

  • Mia reflects on her progression from the Kingston job (nearly arrested at a country club) to this high-stakes political assignment.
  • She receives her third set of instructions: get Andrew Marshall to the Hilton Head conference, where Matt plans to record him with a woman.
  • Mia travels to Savannah to meet Devon in person, asking him to be on standby for unspecified technical support.
  • She discovers that the honey trap plan is weak—Matt failed to research Marshall’s character.
  • Mia spontaneously invites a group of powerful but corrupt politicians to Marshall’s suite for a private cocktail hour.
  • She spikes Marshall’s beer with a sedative, rendering him unconscious on the balcony.
  • As the party devolves, she signals the hired women (the “girls”) to initiate compromising encounters with the other politicians.

Character Development

Mia (Evie / alias Izzy Williams / alias Mia Bianchi):
This chapter marks a pivotal evolution. She moves from following orders blindly to proactively shaping outcomes. Her decision to recruit Devon independently shows she is learning to protect herself. The internal conflict over ruining Andrew Marshall—a decent man—highlights her growing moral awareness, yet she suppresses guilt to survive, calling herself a “ghost passing through.” The Kingston job taught her that luck won’t last; now she builds contingency plans.

Andrew Marshall:
Though not a viewpoint character, his portrayal as genuinely good, loyal to his wife, and resistant to the political game deepens the reader’s sympathy. His squeaky-clean nature is the very quality that forces Mia to take extreme measures.

Matt:
His incompetence is exposed. He designed a plan that would have failed without Mia’s intervention, suggesting he is not yet ready for the “big leagues.” Mia’s strategic override indicates she may soon surpass him.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Identity as a Tool:
Mia’s constructed background (reshaped age, college history, fake photos) illustrates how identity is a weapon. The effort to appear 27 while being 22 underscores the performance required in her work.

The Ghost Motif:
Mia refers to herself as a “ghost passing through.” Yet seeing the origami swan in Miles’s room (from the Kingston job) proves she leaves traces. This tension between invisibility and impact recurs.

Building a Team / Trust:
Her partnership with Devon is built on mutual reliance outside Mr. Smith’s hierarchy. The “trial phase” and the symbolic payment of carrot cake from Matt (knowing her favorite) show that trust can be exploited or earned.

Moral Compromise:
Drugging Andrew and engineering a scenario that could destroy his career—despite her belief he would not cheat—forces Mia to confront her own ethics. She justifies it as survival, but the guilt “bubbles to the surface.”

Why This Chapter Matters

  • It provides the most detailed look yet at Mia’s operational methods and her growth from a “messy” amateur to a meticulous planner.
  • It introduces Devon, a crucial ally who will likely play a role in later chapters.
  • The chapter reframes the reader’s understanding of the political corruption angle: Mr. Smith wants to “own” future governors, not just steal assets.
  • It deepens the moral ambiguity: Mia is not a mere grifter but a woman forced to harm decent people to advance in a ruthless system.
  • The cliffhanger—Mia executing a better plan while Matt’s fails—raises suspense about how the weekend will conclude.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Mia decide to recruit Devon before she even receives the full set of instructions for the Hilton Head job?
Mia suspects that Matt’s inexperience will lead to a flawed plan. After the Kingston incident, she understands the value of having someone loyal who will protect her even if the official support falls through. She wants a partner, not just a vendor.

2. How does Mia’s method of dealing with Andrew Marshall differ from what Matt intended?
Matt planned a honey trap: a woman seducing Andrew while cameras recorded. Mia knows Andrew will resist, so she drugs him and instead lures corrupt politicians into his suite. She uses the evening to create compromising situations for them, benefiting Andrew’s political network and still delivering blackmail material to Mr. Smith.

3. What does the origami swan seen in Miles Kingston’s room symbolize for Mia?
It reminds her that she is not completely invisible. Despite her ghost-like existence, the swan she made with Miles years ago remains displayed, proving she left a mark on someone’s life. This small anchor of humanity contrasts with her current willingness to destroy Andrew.

Navigation