Chapter 31: 12th February—Late
Spoiler Warning: This page contains detailed spoilers for Chapter 31 of Emily Wilde's Compendium of Lost Tales. If you haven't read this chapter, proceed with caution.
Summary
Emily wakes to fine weather and a palpable sense of homecoming. She returns with Arna, Wendell’s stepmother and the murderer of his family, to the mortal cottage. Lilja and Margret, though unsettled, accept the former queen out of trust in Emily. Lilja bluntly offers to bind her, but Emily declines. Margret, curious about testing her baking on a novel guest, serves apple cake. Arna claims to respect hospitality, then ruins the tea by adding excessive leaves. While Emily goes outside to turn the stepping-stones back over, Arna casts a glamour on a sentimental painting, turning it into a scene of wildflowers and cavorting nudes. Lilja stifles her irritation. The group then travels through the stepping-stones and emerges not in the forest but inside Wendell’s private apartments—a development that surprises Emily, who notes the door has been moved. Arna dons an elegant glamour, leaving her hair tangled and feet bare as a gesture of humility.
A wave of terror and curiosity follows as they walk to the Monarchs’ Grove. Servants, courtiers, and common fae alike trail behind, some climbing trees to witness the spectacle. Emily settles Shadow with faerie salve in their bedroom before rejoining the procession. In the scarred Grove, Wendell sits on his throne, pale and sleepless, with Orga in his lap and the possessed cloak grumbling. He strides forward the moment he sees Emily and pulls her into a long embrace, terrified she would not return. Emily begins her prepared apology, but Wendell interrupts: he immediately agrees to let Arna live, not out of mercy, but because he cannot bear the thought of Emily endangering herself again. He then anxiously asks if she is unhappy in his realm, offering library improvements and copies of Cambridge’s dryadology books. Emily reassures him and, teasing, reminds him he still owes her a tour of the kingdom.
Arna kneels and professes a newfound desire for a humble life, claiming the Veil taught her wisdom. Niamh objects, demanding at least imprisonment; Lord Taran warns that Arna will never change and remains a threat. Emily counters that binding enchantments and confinement will suffice, and she even muses that the absence of enemies might drive a monarch mad. Wendell, exasperated but resigned, agrees to make the stepmother a “pet” or object of study. Lord Taran notes that Wendell is following the whims of his wife, but does not press further. The chapter closes with Wendell smiling and promising to finally give Emily her promised tour of the kingdom.
Key Events
- Emily and Arna arrive at the cottage; Lilja and Margret reluctantly show hospitality.
- Arna botches tea-making and glamours a painting, causing tension.
- The party steps through the altered door and emerges in Wendell’s private quarters.
- Servants recognize the former queen; a vast crowd of Folk gathers as they proceed to the Monarchs’ Grove.
- Emily sees the Grove scarred by poison, but the main oak and thrones remain whole.
- Wendell, pale and sleepless, embraces Emily, instantly concedes to spare Arna, and confesses his fear that she was unhappy.
- Arna kneels, begging surrender; Niamh and Lord Taran voice objections.
- Emily proposes binding Arna’s powers and confining her, and Wendell agrees.
- Wendell confirms Emily’s happiness and finally promises the long-awaited tour of the kingdom.
Character Development
Emily Wilde: Her scholar’s resolve shines through. She returns in muddy wellies and an ink-stained shift, yet commands the Folk’s attention precisely because she stops trying to impersonate a queen. Her mental rehearsal of a formal speech is a window into her academic rigidity, but she adapts when Wendell’s emotional reaction derails her plan. Her teasing remark about the tour shows a growing ease in her role.
Wendell: The king’s fears for Emily’s safety outweigh his deep-seated hatred for Arna. He concedes not because he believes in redemption, but because Emily’s absence terrified him enough to override his own wishes. His anxious questioning about her happiness reveals a vulnerable side, while his offhand agreement to treat Arna as a “pet” or research subject underscores his emotionally driven, pragmatic love.
Arna: The former queen performs humility with theatrical flair, swapping a bathrobe for a midnight gown and spouting poetic lines about nature. Her trembling before facing Wendell hints at genuine fear, but Lord Taran’s skepticism suggests her transformation may be as calculated as her glamour. Her ruined tea and painting mishap inject dark comedy into her entrance.
Lilja and Margret: Their gruff acceptance of Arna—despite knowing her crimes—highlights the depth of their trust in Emily. Lilja’s bluntness and Margret’s culinary curiosity provide a grounding, mortal contrast to faerie spectacle.
Lord Taran and Niamh: They voice the practical and moral arguments against leniency. Taran’s weary warning that Arna can always find a loophole serves as a note of unresolved tension.
Themes, Symbols, and Motifs
Theme – Love Over Vengeance: Wendell’s instantaneous decision to spare Arna to protect Emily from future danger elevates personal attachment above the impetus for revenge. The chapter suggests that love, not justice, becomes the new foundation for ruling.
Theme – Power and Authentic Queenship: Emily’s disheveled, unprepared appearance contrasts with Arna’s glamour and even with her own earlier attempts to dress as a queen. The Folk’s avid stares signal that true power may lie in unpolished authenticity rather than ornament.
Theme – The Utility of Enemies: Emily’s scholarly observation that a lack of opposition could drive a monarch to madness introduces the idea that threat—even from a deposed queen—might keep a ruler sharp. It reframes the conflict with Arna as a potentially useful challenge.
Symbol – The Scarred Monarchs’ Grove: Poisoned but with the central oak untouched, the Grove mirrors the kingdom itself: damaged by Arna’s reign yet fundamentally resilient. Wendell’s throne on healthy roots symbolizes the endurance of legitimate rule.
Symbol – Glamour and the Painting: Arna’s alteration of a sentimental painting embodies her invasive, selfish artistry. It’s a small act of vandalism that foreshadows the difficulty others will have trusting her transformation.
Motif – Public Spectacle: The enormous crowd that trails Emily and Arna transforms a personal confrontation into a piece of theatre. The harpist who starts a ballad and is hastily shushed reinforces how every private moment in Faerie can become communal story.
Motif – Speech-Giving as Scholarly Ritual: Emily repeatedly tries to deliver her prepared argument, and her irritation at being interrupted reflects her reliance on structured logic. Wendell’s dismissal of that logic in favor of emotional urgency marks a clash between her academic world and his intuitive Faerie nature.
Why This Chapter Matters
Chapter 31 resolves the immediate tension of Arna’s fate without a violent climax, instead pivoting on Wendell’s devotion to Emily. It cements Emily’s position not by diplomatic skill or queenly attire, but through Wendell’s absolute prioritization of her safety. The decision to keep Arna alive—under watch—opens future narrative possibilities: will she truly reform, or will Taran’s warning prove prophetic? The chapter also addresses Emily’s lingering insecurity about belonging in Faerie. Wendell’s anxious offer to steal a library and her cheerful demand for a tour show the couple negotiating a life together on their own terms. Finally, the immense Folk turnout hints at Emily’s rising stature, earned not through glamour but through the raw display of having survived the Veil and returned with a formidable prisoner.
Study Questions and Answers
-
Why does Wendell agree to spare Arna so quickly, and what does this reveal about his priorities as king?
Wendell’s first thought upon seeing Emily is relief, not vengeance. He explicitly states that he cannot risk her undertaking another dangerous quest, so he consents immediately to avoid provoking her. This reveals that his personal bond with Emily now trumps even his deepest grudges. His kingship is becoming anchored in love and partnership rather than pure authority. -
How does Emily’s shabby appearance affect the gathered Folk, and what might it symbolize about her rule?
The Folk stare at her with “an avidity they had never displayed before,” perhaps because she is entirely unpretentious. Having abandoned her attempts to mimic courtly elegance, she commands attention through sheer authenticity. This symbolizes that real influence in Faerie may come not from performing a role, but from being so confident in one’s own nature that no performance is needed. -
What is the significance of Lord Taran’s warning that Arna will remain a threat, and how does Emily’s response reflect her scholarly temperament?
Taran argues that Arna’s apparent change is a cunning act, and that any enchantment binding her can be undone. Emily counters not with blind faith but with a scholarly hypothesis: that a total absence of enemies might cause a monarch’s decline, perhaps driving them to invent imaginary foes. She treats the situation as a research problem—can a controlled threat be beneficial?—illustrating her tendency to analyze even moral crises through academic frameworks.