Chapter 4: Melina – Summary & Analysis
Spoiler Warning: This page reveals the entire plot and ending of Chapter 4. Continue only if you have read the chapter.
Summary
In May 2013, Melina Green recalls her final semester at Bard College. Her mentor, Professor Bufort, pressures her to write something personally vulnerable for a playwriting festival. She creates Reputation, a play drawn from her own high‑school experience of sexual coercion after being ghosted by her dying mother’s tragedy and latched onto by an older boy. Against Bufort’s knowledge, Melina adds an epilogue in which an unnamed narrator mirrors Bufort’s own habitual shoulder‑rubbing and his demand to “show me what scares you.” At the competition, New York Times critic Jasper Tolle dismisses the work as adolescent “TYA” fare, mocks its emotional rawness, and tells her to avoid autobiographical material because she becomes “difficult” when criticised. Bufort, humiliated by the implication of harassment, gives her thesis a C+ and refuses to see her. Devastated, Melina discovers a genealogy packet from her father: her ancestor Emilia Bassano, the first published female poet in England (1611). The connection rekindles her sense of lineage and purpose.
Key Events
- Professor Bufort pushes Melina to write something that “scares” her and makes her bleed onto the page.
- Melina writes Reputation, a play about a teenage girl who is gaslit into sexual acquiescence by an older boy after her mother dies.
- She secretly adds an epilogue where the narrator mimics Bufort’s inappropriate touching and his line, “Show me what scares you.”
- Jasper Tolle judges the competition; he labels the play “kiddie theatre,” calls the epilogue tacked on, and advises Melina to avoid personal subjects or risk being labeled difficult.
- Bufort punishes her with a C+ on her thesis (comment: “Requires too much suspension of disbelief”) and locks her out of his office.
- Andre, her best friend and roommate, consoles her and reaffirms his loyalty.
- Melina’s father sends a genealogy packet identifying Emilia Bassano, England’s first published female poet, as her ancestor; this discovery connects Melina to a long history of silenced women writers.
Character Development
- Melina Green: Moves from a guarded but acclaimed student to someone who risked radical honesty and was professionally crushed. She learns that exposure is weaponised by powerful men, and vows never to write so personally again—until the discovery of Emilia Bassano reawakens the possibility of resilience across generations.
- Professor Bufort: Revealed as a predator who uses physical closeness and emotional grooming under the guise of mentorship. When exposed even obliquely, he retaliates with academic ruin.
- Andre: Provides unwavering emotional support, humorous deflection, and fierce partisanship. He is the only person on campus who defends Melina and plans to keep their New York dreams alive.
- Jasper Tolle: Embodies the gatekeeping critic who dismisses women’s stories as “small” while lauding male‑centred work. His casual cruelty silences an emerging voice.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- History Written by the Powerful: The chapter opens with the Lebombo bone calendar, a 43,000‑year‑old artifact tracking a 29‑day cycle, which Melina’s anthropology professor uses to argue that men erased women’s contributions. This motif frames the entire episode: theatre gatekeepers erase Melina’s story, just as women’s writing was suppressed in Bassano’s century.
- Vulnerability as a Weapon: Bufort demands emotional exposure, but when Melina complies, the same openness is flipped into a critique of her character and used to justify harsh punishment.
- Sexual Coercion and Reputation: Reputation dramatises how girls are coerced into sex under threat of social ruin, and how their refusals are rewritten by boys. The epilogue extends that dynamic to a faculty‑student power imbalance.
- Gender Bias in Criticism: Tolle’s dismissal—“those don’t read as…small”—and his praise of a male‑focused superhero play highlight the double standard Melina faces as a female finalist.
- Ancestral Legacy: The packet on Emilia Bassano connects Melina to an Elizabethan poet who published against all odds. It suggests that the struggle for women’s authorship is transhistorical and that lineage can be a source of strength.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter is the fulcrum of the modern storyline. It chronicles the formative trauma that will steer Melina’s decisions later in the novel: the public humiliation, the institutional silencing, and the punishment for speaking back. Her encounter with Jasper Tolle and Bufort’s betrayal explain why she might later hide behind a pseudonym or resist putting her own name on her work. The discovery of Emilia Bassano forges the temporal link between Melina’s present and the Elizabethan past, giving the novel its dual‑timeline structure and validating the title By Any Other Name. It also concretises the theme that women writers have always been forced to navigate—and sometimes subvert—male authority to be heard.
Study Questions and Answers
-
Why does Melina add the unauthorised epilogue to Reputation? What does it reveal about her intentions?
The epilogue transforms the play from a personal memory into an indictment of ongoing harassment. By inserting Bufort’s words and touch, Melina highlights that the same coercive pattern she endured as a teenager is being repeated by her mentor. The scene shows she can no longer separate her private pain from the institutional pressure to stay silent. -
How does Jasper Tolle’s criticism reflect broader gender inequality in theatre?
Tolle dismisses Reputation as adolescent “TYA” while praising a play about male superheroes in therapy. He tells Melina that autobiographical writing makes her “difficult” and that her female protagonist is “unlikable,” yet he doesn’t apply the same yardstick to male‑centred coming‑of‑age classics. His judgement illustrates how women’s stories are belittled as niche or overly emotional. -
What is the significance of Emilia Bassano at the end of the chapter?
Emilia Bassano—the first published woman poet in England in 1611—becomes a bloodline for Melina’s own writerly identity. After being told her voice doesn’t matter, Melina sees that a female ancestor wrote successfully in an even more restrictive era. The discovery reframes her expulsion from the Bard theatre world as part of a longer history of silencing, and plants the seed for reclaiming authorship.