Characters Amari and the Night Brothers B.B. Alston

Dylan Van Helsing: Betrayal, Hidden Magic, and the Fight for Magician Supremacy

Overview

Dylan Van Helsing begins as a polished, popular Junior Agent trainee from one of the Bureau’s most powerful legacy families. Beneath his confident exterior, he is a born magician—an illusionist and technologist—who has spent his entire life hiding his true nature. Over the course of the novel, Dylan moves from reluctant ally to full antagonist, ultimately betraying Amari to pursue a vision of magician supremacy. His story raises uncomfortable questions about secrecy, resentment, and the cost of belonging to a world that fears what you are.

Back to main book page

Plot Role

Dylan functions as both a mentor figure and a foil to Amari. Early on, he provides crucial insider information about Quinton’s disappearance and the Bureau’s failure to act on a ransom letter from Moreau’s apprentice. He partners with Amari during the tryouts, helps erase Lara’s blackmail video, and teaches Amari illusion magic at his family’s lake house. These actions build trust, making his eventual betrayal deeply personal.

In the climax, Dylan reveals he has been Moreau’s partner for two years. He stole the Black Book, framed his own sister Maria, and helped set up the kidnapping of VanQuish. When Moreau tries to sacrifice Amari to resurrect the Night Brother Vladimir, Dylan hesitates—then strikes Moreau with a Stun Stick. This moment of partial redemption is immediately undercut when he demands Amari join his cause. After she refuses, he attacks her, and the confrontation ends with Amari’s magic erupting in a dramatic burst of power.

Motivations and Traits Shown Through Actions

Dylan’s core motivation is a desire for magicians to live openly and without fear. He tells Amari, “We shouldn’t have to hide what we are. A true magician cannot serve two masters.” This belief is not unreasonable on its surface—the Bureau does persecute born magicians, and Dylan has witnessed this prejudice firsthand. His error lies in the method he chooses: aligning with a villain who aims to terrorize the supernatural world into submission.

Several traits drive his decisions:

  • Resentment: He resents the Bureau for forcing him to lie about his magic. When Amari complains about being treated unfairly, he replies, “Easy for you to say. Nobody even knows you’re a magician. Everyone wants to be friends with you.” This reveals a deep bitterness that he has concealed behind charm.

  • Manipulation: Dylan is a skilled deceiver. He feigns shock at his sister’s betrayal, uses hybrid attacks on his own home to gain sympathy, and positions himself as Amari’s closest ally while secretly working against her. His ability to maintain this double life for two years demonstrates patience and cold calculation.

  • Moral Ambivalence: Dylan does not enjoy cruelty for its own sake. When Moreau prepared to kill Amari, Dylan stopped him, saying, “I can’t just watch her die.” This suggests he still values Amari on some level, even as he pursues goals that require her cooperation or elimination.

Chronological Arc

  1. Introduction: Dylan first appears at the Winter Wonderland Welcome Social, where he shares classified information about the ransom letter for VanQuish. He presents himself as a reluctant insider who wants to help.

  2. Alliance: During the first tryout, he partners with Amari in the Wakeful Dream and later helps her study for the treasure hunt. He adopts the team name “VanQuish 2.0” and teaches Amari illusion magic at his family’s lake house.

  3. Cracks Appear: When Amari suspects Maria is Moreau’s apprentice, Dylan avoids her and pairs with Lara in Sky Sprint training. He eventually reconciles with Amari, asking her to keep an open mind about his sister.

  4. The Vault Incident: After Maria steals the Black Book, Dylan feigns shock and frames Agent Magnus for deactivating the Bureau’s shields. He then helps Amari and Elsie escape the Bureau to pursue the Black Key.

  5. Final Betrayal: At Dr. Underhill’s cabin, Moreau reveals Dylan’s true role. Dylan admits to everything—stealing the book, framing Maria, and working with Moreau for two years. He betrays Moreau to save Amari, then immediately tries to recruit her to his cause.

  6. Aftermath: Dylan is taken into Bureau custody. His sister Lara thanks Amari for bringing Maria home, saying, “about Dylan, I had no idea…” This suggests Dylan’s family was genuinely unaware of his double life.

Relationships

Amari Peters

Dylan and Amari share a complicated bond. He is the first person at the Bureau who treats her as an equal investigator, and their partnership produces genuine moments of connection—such as when they create the glass “Amari Blossom” flower. However, Dylan’s friendship is instrumental. He admits that every triumph in the tryouts “kept me close, while also allowing me to remain inside the Department of Supernatural Investigations long enough to use my tech magic to figure out its wards and security systems.” The relationship is ultimately one of exploitation, though Dylan’s hesitation to let Amari die suggests real affection beneath the manipulation.

Lara Van Helsing

Dylan and his twin sister have a strained relationship. Lara blackmails Amari with the spell book; Dylan secretly erases the video using tech magic. Lara is disqualified from the finale after using inside information, while Dylan passes an integrity test. The siblings are in competition, and Dylan’s decision to betray his family is a choice to put magician identity above blood ties.

Quinton and Maria Van Helsing

Dylan’s hatred of the Bureau extends to his sister and her partner. He set up their kidnapping and framed Maria for the vault theft, hoping to destroy “people’s memory of her too.” This is one of his most cruel actions—betraying a sibling who, according to Maria, “taught him how to keep his magic a secret.” Maria later remarks, “At some point he started keeping secrets from me too,” indicating a long, quiet drift.

Raoul Moreau

Dylan first contacted Moreau over the othernet using tech magic. For two years, he served as Moreau’s inside agent, betraying the Bureau and VanQuish. However, their alliance was pragmatic, not loyal. Dylan ultimately attacks Moreau to prevent Amari’s death, showing that his personal relationships occasionally override his ideological commitments.

Key Decisions and Consequences

Decision Consequence
Warn Moreau that VanQuish was coming to arrest him Enables Moreau’s escape and sets the story’s conflict in motion
Steal the Black Book and frame Maria Destroys his sister’s reputation; Amari believes Maria is the traitor
Frame Agent Magnus using Bureau shield codes Magnus is arrested; Amari decides to pursue the Black Key alone
Betray Moreau to save Amari Prevents Amari’s death, but Moreau’s magic is stolen, not destroyed
Refuse Amari’s rejection of his plan Leads to an open confrontation; Amari’s magic erupts and defeats him

Each choice narrows Dylan’s options. By the end, he is alone, defeated, and in custody—having alienated everyone who trusted him, including his own family.

Theme and Symbol Connections

  • Prejudice and Identity: Dylan’s arc embodies the question, “What happens when a person is hated for something they cannot change?” He chooses to fight prejudice with fear and domination, exactly the tactics used against him. Amari represents the alternative path: changing minds through openness and example.
  • Betrayal and Trust: Dylan’s betrayal is the novel’s most painful, precisely because he earns Amari’s trust. It illustrates how prejudice can corrupt even loving relationships.
  • Belonging and Acceptance: Dylan never felt truly accepted at the Bureau. His search for belonging led him to Moreau and the League of Magicians. The scene where he shows Amari his family’s lake house—the one place he felt free—is heartbreaking in retrospect; he is showing her the prison walls, not the escape.

For more on these themes, see:

5 Book-Specific Questions and Answers

1. How long was Dylan working with Moreau before the events of the novel? They first made contact over the othernet two years before the story begins. Dylan used tech magic to communicate secretly with Moreau.

2. Why does Dylan reveal the truth to Amari at the cabin? He does not willingly reveal it. Moreau forces the confession, wanting Amari to understand how thoroughly she had been deceived. Dylan admits everything because he cannot deny proof in front of his partner.

3. Does Dylan really care about Amari, or is she just a tool? The text suggests both. He uses her to gain access to Bureau secrets, but he also risks his alliance with Moreau to prevent her death. When Moreau dismisses Amari as merely a sacrifice, Dylan protests, “You said she didn’t have to die.” His final plea for her to join him mixes coercion with genuine desire for partnership.

4. What happens to Dylan after the final battle? He is taken into custody by the Bureau. In the epilogue, Lara confirms Dylan is imprisoned, and Amari receives a card from the League of Magicians, implying Dylan’s connection to that organization may still affect the story.

5. Could Dylan have chosen a different path? The novel frames his choices as avoidable. Amari faces the same prejudice at the Bureau, yet she rejects revenge and instead tries to change minds. Dylan’s trajectory suggests that hiding one’s identity for too long can curdle into bitterness, but that outcome is not inevitable.

Explore the ending and lingering questions | Discussion and FAQ