Chapter 79: The Arrest of Cardinal Ascolani
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
Jason enters the Apostolic Palace on the pope’s direct authority and walks unannounced to the Secretariat of State. He had travelled to Rome the previous day with Father Giumenta to brief the pope on everything that happened in Siena and Florence. The pope apologised for trusting false information; Jason accepted on one condition: that he be allowed to deliver the news of Ascolani’s removal in person. Inside Ascolani’s opulent office, Jason presents the evidence: Thomas Dewberry is dead, the mobile phone retrieved from him contains incriminating messages from Ascolani, two priests have given sworn statements about moving the rifle, and the intermediary who connected Ascolani to Dewberry has been granted immunity and testified that Ascolani ordered Jason’s death. Ascolani initially scoffs, but Jason then announces that the pope has ordered his immediate removal from the Secretariat of State and the Entity and his suspension from all ecclesiastical duties. Ascolani orders Jason to leave, but instead Jason admits two Swiss Guardsmen and Cardinal Stamm. Ascolani is arrested. Stamm quotes St. Augustine about the insufficiency of human merit. Jason thinks the matter is closed, but Stamm warns that while it is over in the Vatican, trouble continues in Florence.
Key Events
- Jason enters the Vatican and confronts Cardinal Ascolani without an appointment.
- He details the evidence chain linking Ascolani to the killings: Dewberry’s phone, sworn priest statements, and an immunity-granted intermediary.
- The pope had already decided to remove and suspend Ascolani; Jason insisted on being the one to deliver the news.
- Ascolani remains defiant, but when Swiss Guards arrive he relents and is led away.
- Cardinal Stamm reflects on the church’s weakness for ambitious men and quotes St. Augustine.
- The chapter closes with Stamm’s hint that the danger is not finished in Florence.
Character Development
- Jason: Acts as the pope’s personal representative, demonstrating both authority and a sense of closure. He forgives the pope but bargains for the satisfaction of confronting Ascolani directly. His quick thinking with the evidence shows he has learned from the investigation.
- Cardinal Ascolani: Maintains a facade of contempt and denial even as the evidence piles up. His will finally breaks when faced with Swiss Guards, revealing a bully who folds when cornered.
- Cardinal Stamm: Reveals his own past involvement with Thomas Dewberry but justifies it as defensive with papal consent. His Augustine quote underscores his humility and contrast to Ascolani’s ambition.
- The Pope: Offstage, he acknowledges his earlier error and moves toward resignation, believing the church needs younger leadership.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- Abuse of power in the Vatican: Ascolani’s use of the Entity for murder and his manipulation of the papal office for personal ambition are exposed. Stamm’s comment about “weak men with huge ambitions who rise to power” captures the central institutional critique.
- Justice and mercy: The pope grants forgiveness to Jason, and Jason in turn forgives the pope but insists on accountability for Ascolani. The immunity deal for the intermediary balances justice with pragmatism.
- The Entity as a hidden arm: The secret intelligence service becomes a symbol of unchecked power within the church; Ascolani corrupted it for criminal ends.
- St. Augustine’s insight: “The sufficiency of my merit is to know that my merit is not sufficient” – spoken by Stamm, it contrasts self-aware humility with Ascolani’s arrogance.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter provides the climax of the Ascolani conspiracy. The secretary of state is publicly exposed and arrested, resolving a major plot thread that has driven much of the novel’s tension. It also signals the pope’s intention to resign, which will have far‑reaching consequences for the church’s leadership and the upcoming conclave. At the same time, Stamm’s final line – “It may be here, but not in Florence” – keeps the narrative stakes alive, promising that the challenges are not yet over and that the Medici intrigue continues to require resolution.
Study Questions
-
What specific pieces of evidence does Jason present to prove Ascolani’s involvement with Thomas Dewberry?
Jason lists the mobile phone from Dewberry containing call logs and texts from Ascolani, sworn statements from two priests who moved the rifle, and the testimony of the intermediary who connected Ascolani to Dewberry – the latter granted immunity and stating that Ascolani ordered Jason’s death. -
Why does the pope decide to resign, and how does Jason react?
The pope believes he was deceived by Ascolani and that the church needs younger, more vital leadership. Jason urges him not to resign, but the pope insists, feeling that his error makes it imperative to stand aside. -
How does Cardinal Stamm distinguish his own past use of Thomas Dewberry from Ascolani’s?
Stamm admits he hired Dewberry but says he used him only in “the most dire situations” and always in a defensive posture with the full knowledge and consent of the pope. He contrasts this with Ascolani’s offensive and criminal use of the killer.