The Medici Return – Chapter 5: Thomas Dewberry at Stonehenge
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
Thomas Dewberry drives from London to Stonehenge, reflecting on his childhood journey into violence. He recalls the five stages of “violentization” that turned him into a killer with no conscience. At the monument, he meets his intermediary, Bartolomé, using code words to confirm identity. Bartolomé passes on an additional request from their benefactor: the assassination of a cardinal, staged to appear as a suicide. Despite his usual preference for careful preparation, Dewberry accepts the job, understanding the unusual nature of killing a prelate. He leaves with a sealed envelope of instructions.
Key Events
- Dewberry drives through the English countryside, contemplating his violent history.
- He recalls the systematic violentization process: brutalization, violent coaching, belligerency, violent performances, and virulency.
- At age seventeen, he beat a bully to death with a cricket bat and disposed of the body.
- He arrives at Stonehenge and joins a VIP tour.
- Dewberry approaches Bartolomé and uses a code phrase (“hanging stones”) to confirm identity.
- Bartolomé corrects the phrase (“stone gallows”) and shares a legend about Merlin moving the stones.
- Bartolomé reveals an additional assignment: kill a cardinal and make it look like suicide, by the end of the week.
- Dewberry hesitates but ultimately accepts the contract, noting the reference to the Council of Trent and Inquisitorial manual.
- Bartolomé hands him a sealed envelope with details and leaves.
- Dewberry mentally prepares to deliver the required death.
Character Development
- Thomas Dewberry: The chapter deepens our understanding of Dewberry as a methodical, conscience-free killer. He fully acknowledges his lack of morality and emotional structure. His acceptance of the cardinal’s murder shows he is willing to stretch his usual caution when the price is right.
- Bartolomé: Serves as the mysterious envoy who handles communications. He is knowledgeable about history and legends, and he questions the unusual request but dutifully passes it on. He remains an enigmatic figure, a conduit between the benefactor and Dewberry.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- Violentization: The chapter explicitly outlines a five-stage process of becoming a violent individual, attributing Dewberry’s nature to childhood trauma and systemic abuse rather than innate evil.
- Stonehenge: The ancient monument symbolizes mystery, pagan ritual, and hidden knowledge. Its ambiguous history mirrors the opacity of the conspiracy Dewberry serves. The code words tied to the monument emphasize secrecy and misdirection.
- Inquisitorial Doctrine: The quote from the Directorium Inquisitorum (“punishment does not take place primarily … for the correction … but for the public good”) justifies violence as a tool for social control, aligning with the benfactor’s motives.
- Suicide as Cover: The demand that the cardinal’s death appear self-inflicted introduces a motif of maintaining plausible deniability and protecting the hidden order.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter shifts the stakes from a general conspiracy to a direct, high-profile assassination. It reveals Dewberry’s full backstory, making him a more nuanced—and frightening—antagonist. The explicit mention of a cardinal as a target signals that the plot involves the Catholic Church at high levels. The use of Stonehenge as the meeting place adds a layer of historical and symbolic weight, linking the present intrigue to ancient mysteries.
Study Questions and Answers
-
Question: What five stages of “violentization” does Thomas Dewberry describe, and how did each manifest in his childhood? Answer: The stages are brutalization (witnessing and experiencing violence from his father), violent coaching (father forcing him to fight), belligerency (threatening a nun and carrying out the threat), violent performances (actively hurting others without reservation), and virulency (commitment to violence without remorse). Each stage followed from the previous, culminating in his first murder at age seventeen.
-
Question: Why does Dewberry accept the contract to kill a cardinal despite his usual preference for careful planning? Answer: Dewberry is swayed by the doubled fee and the unusual nature of the request, which challenges his routine. He also notes that the benefactor’s reference to the Council of Trent and Inquisitorial manual implies a higher purpose he is willing to serve. Bartolomé’s support and the guarantee of a Swiss account payment remove financial doubt.
-
Question: What is the significance of the code phrase “hanging stones” and “stone gallows” at Stonehenge? Answer: The phrases confirm that Dewberry and Bartolomé are on the same mission without exposing themselves to eavesdroppers. The discrepancy (“hanging stones” versus “stone gallows”) acts as a test: if the wrong response came, Dewberry would know the intermediary was compromised. The dark imagery of gallows also foreshadows the impending death.