Chapter summaries Unnatural Death Patricia Cornwell

Unnatural Death: Chapter 40 Summary & Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Benton and Kay Scarpetta drive to Abel Dairy to meet Ledger Smithson, who claims to have information about Mike Abel’s death. They find the dairy farm deserted and notice a path leading from the field where Mike was killed. Following it, they discover a windowless blockhouse with several vehicles, including a white van similar to the one near the scene of the earlier attack on Scarpetta. Concerned for Ledger's safety, they next go to Old Comfort Farm, an animal rescue where Ledger volunteers. There they find a black Land Rover (Bonnie Abel’s) and a government Tahoe assigned to FBI agent Patty Mullet. Inside the building, snakes have been set loose, and two bodies lie on the floor in pools of blood. A cobra strikes the glass door. Unable to enter due to the danger, Benton calls 911 and alerts Lucy. Wally Jonas arrives and speculates that Ledger killed both victims and released the snakes. Scarpetta instructs Jonas to use infrared thermometers when the scene is safe. The chapter ends with the group awaiting animal control, uncertain of Ledger’s fate or guilt.

Key Events

  • Benton and Scarpetta drive to Abel Dairy after a call from Ledger Smithson.
  • They notice a path in the cornfield and follow it to a blockhouse with vehicles.
  • Scarpetta photographs the white construction van, later identified as registered to Mike Abel.
  • Unable to reach Ledger, they drive to Old Comfort Farm.
  • At the animal rescue, they see a black Land Rover (Bonnie Abel) and a Tahoe (Patty Mullet).
  • Snakes, including a hooded cobra and a python, are loose inside; two bodies are visible.
  • Benton calls 911 and updates Lucy, who confirms the vehicle registrations.
  • Wally Jonas arrives and suggests Ledger killed the two and released the snakes.
  • Scarpetta gives forensic instructions for when animal control clears the scene.
  • The chapter ends with tension as no one can enter the building.

Character Development

  • Kay Scarpetta shows professional restraint by refusing to enter the snake-filled scene, prioritizing safety over immediate investigation. She also faces personal anxiety about Carrie Grethen’s possible involvement.
  • Benton Wesley demonstrates caution by carrying weapons, alerting Lucy and Tron to their location, and making calm decisions under pressure. He admits he withheld information about Carrie to protect Scarpetta’s peace of mind, straining their trust.
  • Lucy Farinelli (via phone) continues her role as a technical and tactical support, rapidly identifying vehicles and location details.
  • Wally Jonas appears more cynical and quick to judge Ledger, contrasting with Scarpetta’s openness.
  • Ledger Smithson remains absent and ambiguous; the chapter raises questions about whether he is a victim or perpetrator.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs Actually Evidenced Here

  • Trust and Deception: Benton’s past secrecy about Carrie and the unknown reliability of Ledger’s call highlight the difficulty of trusting others. Scarpetta challenges Benton’s justification.
  • Snakes as Symbols: The released snakes—especially the cobra and python—symbolize hidden dangers, betrayal, and the unpredictability of the case. They physically prevent entry, mirroring how secrets block truth.
  • Forensic Limitations: The scene illustrates how environmental hazards (venomous snakes) can halt standard investigation, forcing adaptive measures like infrared thermometers.
  • Animal Rescue as Facade: Old Comfort Farm’s appearance as a petting zoo masks its role in venom sales and possible criminal activity, reinforcing the theme that nothing is as it seems.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter escalates the investigation into Mike Abel’s death by uncovering a possible secondary crime scene and linking the blockhouse to the earlier attack on Scarpetta. The deaths of Bonnie Abel and FBI agent Patty Mullet raise the stakes, suggesting a wider conspiracy. The ambiguity about Ledger’s role—victim or killer—keeps the reader guessing. Additionally, the ongoing threat of Carrie Grethen undercuts any sense of safety, reminding us that past villains can resurface. The chapter forces Scarpetta to confront both external danger and internal doubts about her closest ally.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Scarpetta refuse to enter Old Comfort Farm even though she is the chief medical examiner?
    She prioritizes safety over immediate investigation because the building contains loose venomous snakes, and antivenin is not readily available. Entering would risk her life and Benton’s, and she cannot examine bodies properly under such conditions.

  2. What does the white construction van’s registration to Mike Abel suggest about the blockhouse?
    It implies that Mike Abel may have been involved in activities beyond his dairy farm, possibly connected to the blockhouse. The van’s presence links his death to a broader criminal operation, perhaps involving the venom trade or other illegal enterprises.

  3. How does the chapter develop the theme of trust between Scarpetta and Benton?
    Scarpetta confronts Benton about his seven-year secrecy regarding Carrie Grethen. While Benton claims he wanted to protect her, Scarpetta argues that she should decide what risks to worry about. This conflict shows that trust is fragile and that withholding information, even with good intentions, damages their relationship.

Navigation