Chapter summaries This is Why We Lied Karin Slaughter

Chapter 13 Summary: Faith’s Interview with Penny Danvers

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Faith Mitchell volunteers to interview Penny Danvers, the lodge’s cleaner and bartender, to avoid attending Mercy’s autopsy. Before leaving the hospital, Faith and Will construct a timeline of Mercy’s last hour based on missed calls to Dave and witness reports. Faith drives into the rural mountains, gets lost, and hydroplanes her Mini into a ditch. After digging herself out, she meets Penny Danvers, who appears with a shotgun and her dog. They drive to Penny’s farm, where Penny reveals Mercy’s difficult life: pregnant in high school, rejected by the community, forced into sex work to afford a lawyer for custody of Jon, and later blamed for a fatal car crash that killed her friend Gabbie. Penny explains that the town’s old men—including her own father, the former sheriff—control women’s lives. Mercy was never charged for Gabbie’s death, but Cecil and Bitty tormented her afterward. Faith receives a call from Will: Mercy was twelve weeks pregnant at the time of her murder. The chapter ends with Faith realizing her tire is flat and needing a ride back to the hospital, with Penny pointing to a horse named Rascal.

Key Events

  • Faith reconstructs the timeline of Mercy’s final hour using phone records and Will’s observations.
  • Faith gets lost on gravel roads, crashes into a ditch, and frees her car.
  • Penny Danvers reveals Mercy’s history: teenage pregnancy, custody battle, and the fatal car crash that killed Gabbie.
  • Penny explains that the old men in town (including her father and Cecil) used their power to control women.
  • Will calls to inform Faith that Mercy was twelve weeks pregnant.
  • Faith learns her spare tire is missing; Penny offers the horse Rascal as transportation.

Character Development

  • Faith Mitchell: Shows resilience and resourcefulness during the car accident. Her internal reflections reveal her empathy for Mercy as a fellow mother, and her determination to find the truth despite physical obstacles.
  • Penny Danvers: Initially hostile, she opens up about her own subjugation under her father (the former sheriff) and her sobriety. She becomes a key source of Mercy’s backstory, highlighting the systemic abuse Mercy endured.
  • Mercy McAlpine (through testimony): Emerges as a complex figure – a victim of domestic violence, a mother who fought for her son, a businesswoman who improved the lodge, and someone haunted by a fatal accident she caused while intoxicated.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Control and Patriarchy: The chapter emphasizes how men in positions of power (Cecil, Penny’s father, Dave) exert control over women’s lives. Penny’s speech about “old men” wanting to control everything directly ties to Mercy’s inability to escape her circumstances.
  • Maternal Sacrifice: Faith reflects on what she would do for her children, paralleling Mercy’s willingness to do sex work to regain custody of Jon. The revelation of Mercy’s pregnancy adds a tragic layer to her death.
  • Scars and Haunting: Mercy’s facial scar from the car crash symbolizes her guilt and permanent reminder of Gabbie’s death. Penny notes that Mercy never forgave herself.
  • Locked-Room Mystery: Faith contemplates the classic whodunit trope, noting the obvious suspect (Dave) might not be the killer.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is pivotal because it removes Dave McAlpine as the prime suspect and introduces new motives and suspects. Penny’s testimony establishes that Mercy had powerful enemies in town (Cecil, the former sheriff) and that her death is part of a broader pattern of male control over women’s lives. The revelation that Mercy was twelve weeks pregnant shifts the investigation: pregnancy is a high-risk period for intimate partner homicide, and it raises questions about who the father might be. Faith’s perspective deepens, humanizing Mercy and creating emotional stakes for the reader.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Faith decide to interview Penny instead of attending the autopsy?
    Faith admits she hates autopsies and finds being around dead bodies distressing. She volunteers for the interview to avoid the procedure, even though it means a difficult drive into the mountains.

  2. What does Penny reveal about Mercy’s relationship with her father, Cecil?
    Penny describes Cecil as a controlling man who punished Mercy throughout her life. After Mercy improved the lodge’s profitability, he resented her success. Penny implies Cecil was one of the “old men” who wanted to keep women under their thumb.

  3. How does the discovery that Mercy was pregnant change the investigation?
    The pregnancy adds a powerful motive: homicide is the leading cause of maternal death in the US. Faith and Will now consider that Mercy’s killer might be the father of the baby or someone who wanted to prevent the pregnancy from being known.

Navigation