Chapter summaries The Coworker Freida McFadden

The Coworker – Chapter 4: Unease and a Hidden Past

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Chapter 4 shifts to the present day, following Natalie Farrell on a tense morning at Vixed. She takes a sales call from customer Carmen Salinas, who loves the new Collahealth supplement, while a mysterious turtle figurine sits on Natalie’s desk—a gift from Dawn that seems stained with a dark red substance that could be blood. Natalie is increasingly unsettled that Dawn has not arrived at work by noon. She recalls Dawn’s urgent email from the day before and a strange phone call where she heard the words “Help me.”

Natalie has a brief, affectionate encounter with her boyfriend Caleb McCullough, a website developer she has been dating for nearly two months. She declines his lunch invitation because she must prepare for an important podcast interview about the charity 5K she is organizing in memory of her childhood friend Amelia, who had cerebral palsy. During the interview, a blocked-number call vibrates her phone—similar to the earlier mysterious call—but she lets it go to voicemail, though it distracts her. The chapter ends with Natalie fighting emotion as she explains to the host why the charity is personal: Amelia’s struggle with cerebral palsy and her eventual death.

Key Events

  • Natalie handles a routine sale of Collahealth to a repeat customer but remains fixated on Dawn’s absence.
  • The turtle figurine with a possible blood stain is moved to face the corner of the cubicle; Natalie wonders if it was a cleaned-off gift from Dawn.
  • Caleb McCullough visits Natalie’s cubicle; they share a kiss and mention how much they enjoyed a date the previous night (Chinese food and making out).
  • Natalie asks Caleb if he has seen Dawn; he has not, but she chooses not to tell him about the strange phone call.
  • She gives Caleb a T‑shirt for the upcoming 5K run; he playfully boasts he will beat her.
  • During a podcast interview with Sherri Bell, a blocked call distracts Natalie; she ignores it.
  • Natalie reveals that the charity 5K is dedicated to her childhood best friend Amelia, who died from cerebral palsy—the emotional core of the chapter.

Character Development

  • Natalie Farrell: Shows a caring, if slightly anxious, side—she is worried about Dawn, yet tries to project confidence and professionalism. Her internal conflict between wanting to act and not appear overbearing is evident. Her relationship with Caleb reveals a hopeful, vulnerable side; she is deeply invested in this new romance and sees a future with him. The revelation about Amelia adds depth to her charitable work and suggests a past trauma that drives her.
  • Caleb McCullough: Portrayed as supportive, respectful, and charming. He does not push Natalie physically (leaving after dinner at 9:30) and is excited about the race. His eagerness to start a family hints at personal history (father died young). He remains unaware of Dawn’s trouble, keeping him separate from the mystery.
  • Dawn Schiff (off-page): Her strange absence, the urgent email, and the cryptic “Help me” phone call cast her as a possible victim or in distress. The turtle figurine—potentially from Dawn—may hold a clue.
  • Sherri Bell (podcast host): A minor character who facilitates Natalie’s backstory and the charity exposition.
  • Amelia (mentioned): Natalie’s deceased friend; her memory is the catalyst for the 5K. Her death clearly still affects Natalie, though details are left vague.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • The Turtle Figurine: A key symbol of unease. It may be a gift from Dawn, but its blood-like stain suggests violence or a warning. Natalie’s decision to turn it away from her mirrors her desire to ignore potential danger.
  • Mysterious Phone Calls / Blocked Numbers: Represent hidden threats and unresolved tension. The repeated “Help me” adds an element of desperation and hints that Dawn is in trouble.
  • Charity and Guilt: Natalie’s dedication to the cerebral palsy foundation is linked to her grief for Amelia. The phrase “I hope so” reveals lingering doubt about whether she has done enough—both for Amelia and possibly for Dawn.
  • Romance vs. Duty: Natalie balances her new relationship with Caleb against workplace responsibilities and her concern for Dawn. Her choice to prioritize the interview over Caleb’s lunch shows her commitment to the charity.
  • Appearances and Performance: Natalie’s concern about her lipstick, hair roots, and smiling during sales calls underscores her reliance on projecting a flawless image—even internally.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter deepens the central mystery of Dawn’s disappearance by introducing tangible evidence: the blood‑stained turtle and the blocked call during the interview. It also enriches Natalie’s backstory through the charity cause, making her more sympathetic and giving her a personal motivation beyond mere worry. The development of her relationship with Caleb adds warmth and normalcy, contrasting with the growing dread. The chapter sets up multiple threads—the 5K race, the mystery of Dawn, and the unresolved phone call—that will converge later.

Study Questions and Answers

1. What does the turtle figurine symbolize, and why is Natalie disturbed by it?
The turtle figurine likely symbolizes a potential threat or warning from Dawn. Its dark red stain resembles blood, making Natalie uneasy. By turning it to face the wall, she tries to ignore what it might signify. This connects to the broader mystery of Dawn’s absence.

2. How does Natalie’s personal history with Amelia influence her actions in this chapter?
Natalie’s childhood friend Amelia died from cerebral palsy, which motivates her to organize the annual 5K charity run. Her emotional response during the interview shows that she feels a personal responsibility to honor Amelia’s memory. This history may also make her more sensitive to helping others—like Dawn—who might be in trouble.

3. Why does Natalie choose not to tell Caleb about her worry over Dawn’s absence and the strange phone call?
She wants to appear calm and not come across as a “worrywart” in the early stage of their relationship. Additionally, she is preoccupied with the podcast interview. This decision keeps Caleb out of the loop for now, potentially leaving Natalie to face any danger alone.

Navigation