Chapter summaries Paradox Douglas Preston

Paradox Chapter 44: Revelations and Ritual Murders

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

The chapter opens with Cash entering the Eagle County Sheriff’s Office side conference room, where she finds Sheriff Colcord exhausted after working all night on a corkboard display of the case. Cash herself has spent a sleepless night at the Eagle Valley Library researching torture devices, Communion rituals, UAPs, and the Spanish Inquisition, trying to distract herself from the image of Reno’s dead face.

Cash tells Colcord she no longer believes Paradox is behind the Shrouder murders or that Margie Brooksfield killed Willy Grooms. She explains that Krikor Khachatryan, the controller of Paradox, contacted her via Standish. Khachatryan claimed the money from Grooms was meant to finance an expedition to find a UFO crash site and that members of Paradox are being targeted and killed by a radical Catholic society called Devotio. Cash admits she withheld this information for two days, causing tension with Colcord.

Colcord presses Cash about the missing relic—the piece of the head of Saint John the Baptist—and she admits Reno was transporting it when he was killed, likely for the relic. Overwhelmed with guilt, Cash asks for a moment of silence. Colcord apologizes and softens his tone.

Cash then introduces a historical connection found by a researcher: a painting titled Communion of the Dying (1839) by Alexey Venetsianov depicts a dying woman in white linens with a priest in red—identical to how Grooms and Reno were dressed. She explains the ritual of viaticum (Holy Communion given to dying Catholics) and how it was administered during the Inquisition even to those being executed. Both Grooms and Reno were Catholic, given Communion and wine before death, and their bodies were embalmed and posed. Castillo, who was not Catholic, was murdered without these rites and his body was discarded. Cash theorizes that Devotio is an extreme Catholic cult performing these rituals, believing they are saving souls. The chapter ends with Cash asking why a Catholic secret society would target UFO researchers.

Key Events

  • Cash and Colcord meet at the sheriff’s office after sleepless nights; Cash shares information about Paradox and Devotio.
  • Cash reveals she withheld Krikor Khachatryan’s claims from Colcord for two days, leading to friction.
  • Colcord learns that the relic (Saint John the Baptist’s head fragment) was in Reno’s possession when he died.
  • Cash shows Colcord the Communion of the Dying painting and explains the ritualistic details linking the murders.
  • Cash lays out her theory: Devotio is a Catholic cult that kills targets with sacrament-like rituals depending on the victim’s faith.

Character Development

Agent Cash: Demonstrates vulnerability and guilt over Reno’s death, feeling responsible. She shows determination despite exhaustion, pushing the investigation forward with historical research. Her willingness to admit she withheld information shows growth, though she struggles to fully trust Colcord.

Sheriff Colcord: Initially incredulous and frustrated that Cash kept crucial intel from him, he later softens when he sees her grief. His shift from aggressive to gentle highlights his empathy and ability to prioritize partnership over pride.

Krikor Khachatryan (mentioned): Remains an off-page figure whose claims about Devotio are now taken more seriously by Cash.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Ritual and Religion: The chapter centers on the symbolic meaning of the murder scenes—white linens, viaticum, embalming. These elements transform killings into twisted sacraments, suggesting the killers view themselves as administering last rites rather than committing murder.

  • Secrecy and Trust: Cash’s decision to withhold information from Colcord reflects the broader theme of secrecy within the investigation. The tension between them underscores how withheld knowledge can damage cooperation.

  • Historical Patterns: The connection to the Spanish Inquisition and the Communion of the Dying painting highlights how past religious violence may be repeating itself in modern murders.

  • The Body as Text: How the victims’ bodies are treated (embalmed vs. discarded) communicates the killers’ theology. Catholic victims receive “respectful” treatment; non-Catholic victims are mutilated and disposed of.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 44 is a turning point where Cash’s fragmentary leads finally cohere into a clear hypothesis: the murders are not random but part of a religiously motivated campaign by a secret society called Devotio. This reframes the entire investigation. The chapter also deepens Cash and Colcord’s working relationship, moving from friction toward mutual understanding. The historical evidence (the painting and viaticum ritual) gives the story a tangible link to the past, grounding the thriller in real history. By raising the question of why a Catholic cult would target UFO researchers, the chapter sets up the central mystery for the remainder of the novel.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Cash believe Devotio is responsible for the murders, and what evidence does she present?

Cash believes Devotio is responsible because of the ritualistic elements shared by the murder victims: they were dressed in white linens, given viaticum (Communion) before death, and their bodies were embalmed. She shows Colcord the 1839 painting Communion of the Dying that exactly depicts this scene. She also notes that Castillo, who was not Catholic, was killed without these rites, reinforcing the religious motivation.

2. What is the significance of the missing relic (the head of Saint John the Baptist) in this chapter?

The relic was in Reno’s possession when he was killed. Cash admits that Reno likely died because of it. This connects the relic to the motives of Devotio, suggesting that the cult is also seeking religious artifacts as part of their agenda. It adds a layer of religious artifact theft to the killings.

3. How does the relationship between Cash and Colcord evolve in this chapter?

Initially, Colcord is angry that Cash withheld Khachatryan’s information for two days, accusing her of not cooperating. Cash, in turn, accuses him of dismissing her UFO-connection theory. However, when Cash breaks down with grief over Reno, Colcord softens, apologizes, and speaks gently. This moment of vulnerability creates a new level of trust and mutual respect between them.

Navigation