Chapter 34: Jealousy, Confessions, and Wishing on Stars
Spoiler Notice: This analysis discusses events from A Court of Thorns and Roses Chapter 34 in detail. If you are reading for the first time, proceed with caution.
← Previous Chapter | Return to Book Hub | Next Chapter →
Summary
Feyre wakes from nightmares and avoids breakfast, questioning whether Rhysand’s past kindness was genuine care or merely a strategy to protect his “weapon.” She plays with Tarquin’s borrowed water magic in the bath before Nuala dresses her in seafoam green—deliberately matching Tarquin’s attire. In the main hall, Feyre meets Tarquin, Rhysand, Amren, and Cresseida, pointedly ignoring Rhys throughout.
Tarquin escorts her through multiple treasure vaults beneath the palace. He gifts her a necklace of black diamonds and speaks candidly about wanting an alliance with the Night Court. He reveals he believes Rhysand served as Amarantha’s whore to shield others from her cruelty, and expresses admiration for Feyre’s character. Feyre searches for the Book of Breathings but finds nothing. Returning to her room, she finds Rhys lounging on her bed. Their confrontation escalates: Rhys admits he did not sleep with Cresseida, then confesses his jealousy that Feyre smiled at Tarquin and called him easy to love. He reveals his deeper envy—that Tarquin will never know what it is to “look up at the night sky and wish.” The chapter closes with their toast: “To the stars who listen—and the dreams that are answered.”
Key Events
- Feyre battles nightmares and loneliness, then deliberately avoids Rhys at breakfast.
- She experiments with Tarquin’s water power, shaping animals and butterflies.
- Nuala dresses Feyre in colors matching Tarquin, amplifying their public unity.
- Tarquin gives Feyre a tour of his treasure vaults and gifts her a black diamond necklace.
- Tarquin openly discusses his desire for a Night Court alliance and his belief that Rhys protected others Under the Mountain.
- Feyre searches for the Book but finds no trace in any vault.
- Rhys confronts Feyre in her room; she accuses him of sleeping with Cresseida.
- Rhys clarifies he did not touch Cresseida and admits his jealousy over her emotional openness with Tarquin.
- Rhys shares his vulnerability about never being the “easy” person to love.
- Feyre and Rhys share a symbolic toast to dreamers and starlight.
Character Development
Feyre: This chapter deepens her internal conflict between mission and morality. She feels like a “fox in the chicken coop” and a “lying, two-faced wretch,” yet still craves genuine connection. Her jealousy over Rhys—which she initially denies—reveals growing emotional investment she is reluctant to name. By the chapter’s end, she chooses empathy over distance, meeting Rhys’s vulnerability with compassion.
Rhysand: Rhys peels back another layer of his facade. He admits he did not sleep with Cresseida, revealing his flirtation was purely tactical. His confession about jealousy—that Feyre smiled at Tarquin and found him easy to love—exposes deep-rooted insecurity. Rhys views himself as someone for whom love will never be simple or safe, and this moment of raw honesty marks one of the most vulnerable exchanges between them so far.
Tarquin: The Summer High Lord continues to appear earnest, idealistic, and unguarded. He reveals he looked past Amarantha’s propaganda to see kindness in Feyre, and he suspects Rhysand’s true nature. His desire to dismantle class barriers between High Fae and lesser faeries aligns him philosophically with Rhys’s secret mission, making Feyre’s deception feel heavier.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- Jealousy as a Mirror: Both Feyre and Rhys project their insecurities through jealousy. Feyre fixates on Cresseida; Rhys fixates on Tarquin. The jealousy in this chapter is not about possession but about worthiness—each fears they are not the person someone could easily choose.
- Starlight and Wishing: The chapter’s closing toast—“To the people who look at the stars and wish”—echoes the motif of the Night Court as a place for dreamers and outcasts. Rhys’s “Court of Dreams” is directly invoked as the collection of broken, powerful people who understand that dreams carry a price.
- Masking and Performance: Nuala dresses Feyre to match Tarquin; Rhys plays the detached High Lord; Feyre offers “a pretty, mindless smile.” Everyone performs a role, but the chapter rewards moments where the mask slips.
- Water as Transformation: Feyre’s bath scene, where she shapes water creatures, symbolizes her tentative exploration of the powers she gained from the High Lords. It is a quiet moment of self-claiming, separate from the mission.
Why This Chapter Matters
Chapter 34 marks a crucial emotional turning point in Feyre and Rhysand’s relationship. Until now, their partnership has been defined by bargains, banter, and mission logistics. Here, the armor cracks on both sides. Rhys reveals he wants to be someone Feyre would find easy to love, and Feyre chooses not to retreat from that vulnerability. This exchange reframes their entire dynamic from allies of convenience to two people who recognize a shared loneliness.
Simultaneously, the chapter advances the mission stakes. Feyre’s tour of the vaults—and her failure to locate the Book—tightens the timeline. Tarquin’s open admiration for Feyre and his philosophical alignment with Rhysand make the deception increasingly uncomfortable. The chapter asks: how much betrayal is justified in the name of a greater good?
The final toast is not just a romantic beat. It is a thesis statement for the series’ emotional core: that wishing on stars is an act of defiance, and that the people who do so—despite everything—deserve to have those dreams answered.
Study Questions and Answers
-
Why does Rhysand react so strongly to Feyre smiling at Tarquin? Rhys admits he is jealous of Tarquin’s inherent ease—Tarquin will never have to worry that someone will leave because his life, or his children’s lives, are perpetually threatened. Feyre told Tarquin it would be “easy” to fall in love with him, and Rhys internalizes that as proof he himself will never be the uncomplicated, safe choice. His reaction is less about possessiveness and more about grief for the life he cannot have.
-
How does Feyre’s internal guilt complicate her mission to find the Book? Tarquin treats her with genuine warmth and trust, sharing politically vulnerable information and giving her a priceless gift. Feyre calls herself a “thief, liar, manipulator” and struggles to reconcile her growing respect for Tarquin with her duty to deceive him. This guilt does not stop her mission, but it adds emotional weight and foreshadows the moral cost of their actions.
-
What does the toast “To the stars who listen—and the dreams that are answered” signify in the context of this chapter? The toast explicitly references Rhys’s earlier line about looking up at the night sky and wishing. It transforms what could have been a bleak admission into a shared act of hope. The “stars who listen” are both the literal Night Court sky and the people—like Feyre—who hear Rhys’s unspoken longing. By clinking glasses, Feyre signals she understands him not as her High Lord or handler but as a fellow dreamer.